He then told the audience about a nearly friendly law professor on a Roman holiday. Someone who felt perfectly fine to comment on American law…”
Alito, no doubt encouraged by the scattered laughter and light applause inspired by Boris Johnson’s sniping, then went on to make a completely mundane comment. When he spoke at the United Nations and appeared to compare a decision that may not have been named to Russia’s attack on Ukraine.”
Alito’s comments about the Prime Minister and the Duke of Sussex were inappropriate for Supreme Court justices speaking abroad, and even in the United States for that matter. To do. This is because the Constitution generally leaves these matters exclusively to the President, with occasional Congressional advice and consent. There is no mention of the Constitution of traveling Supreme Court Justices attacking foreign leaders who do not agree with the court’s rulings.
Alito showed in a speech in Rome that he was not Antonin Scalia. His wit and charm impressed many, including those who opposed his conservative politics.
Many Americans were undoubtedly surprised that Alito or any Supreme Court justice would be allowed to make public comments on recent Supreme Court rulings. has taught Americans to always decline or deflect direct answers related to issues that may be brought to court.
Many Americans were probably shocked to hear the Supreme Court Justice giving all sorts of speeches. Judges occasionally make public speeches, but are usually very careful to avoid discussing issues related to pending or future cases. And the question of abortion is always on the record of federal courts across the country, in its potential journey to the Supreme Court.
Public confidence in court does not require judges to avoid all speech, but it does require them to be wise and cautious about the topics they choose. Alito has shown very bad judgment when even jokingly discussing the Roe v. Wade controversy abroad, while lawsuits related to abortion issues are pending in the United States. Discussions of this important matter by Supreme Court justices should take place in open, public American courtrooms, not in front of private groups in foreign public halls.
Source: www.cnn.com
